Italy Imposes €805 Million Fine on Meta for Unconsented Photo Access
Italian regulators fined Meta €805 million for accessing Android users’ photos without consent, demanding the feature be disabled by default and consented to separately within 60 days.
On Saturday, November 14, 2026, Italy’s Data Protection Authority, the Garante, announced a €805 million fine against Meta Platforms Inc. The penalty stems from the Facebook app’s gallery-suggestion feature, which accessed photos, videos and metadata on about 20 million Android phones in Italy without explicit user consent. Meta must disable the feature by default and obtain separate, informed permission within 60 days.
- Meta fined €805 million for unconsented photo access.
- The fine is the largest ever imposed by an Italian regulator on a tech giant.
- Meta must disable the gallery-suggestion feature by default and seek new consent within 60 days.
How the Gallery-Suggestion Feature Worked
The feature, introduced in 2023, scans a user’s phone gallery while they scroll through Facebook and proposes images or videos as post ideas. To enable this, the app requested a single, app-wide permission that covered the entire gallery. The Garante found that the prompt did not clearly state that this permission would also activate the suggestion engine, leaving users unaware that their photo library was being read.
Regulatory Basis and Scope of the Fine
The Garante applied Article 122 of Italy’s privacy code, which treats a smartphone as part of a person’s private sphere. Under this rule, any access to the device’s contents requires free, informed consent—even if no data leaves the phone. The authority noted that the feature was still active for users who had not updated the app and for those who had previously granted access, amplifying the number of affected individuals.
Meta’s Response and Cooperation Issues
Meta’s EU headquarters in Ireland argued that the case should be handled by the European Data Protection Board, citing GDPR jurisdiction. The Garante rejected this, stating the case fell under ePrivacy rules, which do not have a single supervisory authority. Meta’s cooperation was deemed “poor” by the regulator, and the company’s post-complaint changes were considered late and limited to users who updated the app.
Comparative Context of the Penalty
When expressed as a percentage of Meta’s global turnover, the €805 million fine represents about 0.47 %. It is close to the €825 million fine imposed on Uber in the Netherlands and below Meta’s €1.2 billion GDPR fine for data transfers. The Garante also noted that it would investigate a separate cloud-processing feature launched in 2026, though that probe was not part of the current decision.
Implications for Users, Developers, and the Industry
For website owners and developers, the ruling underscores the importance of granular, user-specific permissions and transparent disclosure. The fine demonstrates that regulators will scrutinize any feature that accesses personal data without clear consent, even if the data remains on the device. Companies must ensure that default settings do not enable data access and that consent mechanisms are explicit and separate for each function.
For Meta, the penalty signals a tightening of privacy enforcement in Europe and a potential shift toward stricter compliance for all its platforms, including Instagram and WhatsApp. The decision may prompt other regulators to revisit similar features across the industry, especially those that leverage device data for content recommendation or AI training.
Overall, the Garante’s action serves as a reminder that privacy laws treat personal devices as extensions of private space, and that any access—no matter how innocuous—requires clear, informed consent.



